Therefore remember, that you being in time past Gentiles in the flesh, who are called Uncircumcision by that which is called the Circumcision in the flesh made by hands;
All Commentaries on Ephesians 2:11 Go To Ephesians 2
John Chrysostom
AD 407
There are many things to show the loving-kindness of God. First, the fact, that by Himself He has saved us, and by Himself through such a method as this. Secondly, that He has saved us, as being what we were. Thirdly, that He has exalted us to the place where we are. For all these things both contain in themselves the greatest demonstration of His loving-kindness, and they are the very subjects which Paul is now agitating in his Epistle. He had been saying, that when we were dead through our trespasses, and children of wrath, He saved us; He is now telling us further, to whom He has made us equal. Wherefore, says he, remember; because it is usual with us, one and all, when we are raised from a state of great meanness to corresponding, or perhaps a greater, dignity, not so much as even to retain any recollection of our former condition, being nourished in this our new glory. On this account it is that he says, Wherefore remember.— Wherefore. Why, wherefore? Because we have been created unto good works, and this were sufficient to induce us to cultivate virtue; remember,— for that remembrance is sufficient to make us grateful to our Benefactor,— that you were aforetime Gentiles. Observe how he lowers the superior advantages of the Jews and admires the disadvantages of the Gentiles; disadvantage indeed it was not, but he is arguing with each respectively from their character and manner of life.
Who are called Uncircumcision.
The honor then of the Jews is in names, their perogative is in the flesh. For uncircumcision is nothing, and circumcision is nothing.
By that which is called, says he, Circumcision in the flesh made by hands, that you were at that time separate from Christ, alienated from the commonwealth of Israel, and strangers from the covenants of the promise, having no hope, and without God in the world.
You, says he, who were thus called by the Jews. But why when he is about to show that the benefit bestowed upon them consisted in this, in having fellowship with Israel, does he disparage the Israelitish prerogative? He does not disparage it. In essential points he enhances it, but only in these points, in which they had no fellowship, he disparages it. For further on he says, You are fellow citizens of the saints and of the household of God. Mark, how far he is from disparaging it. These points, says he, are indifferent. Never think, says he, that because ye happen not to be circumcised, and are now in uncircumcision, that there is any difference in this. No, the real trouble was this, the being without Christ, the being aliens from the commonwealth of Israel. Whereas this circumcision is not the commonwealth. Again, the being strangers from the covenants of promise, the having no hope to come, the being without God in this world, all these were parts of their condition. He was speaking of heavenly things; he speaks also of those which are upon earth; since the Jews had a great opinion of these. Thus also Christ in comforting His disciples, after saying, Blessed are they that have been persecuted for righteousness' sake, for theirs is the kingdom of heaven, adds the lesser point of consolation, for so, says He, persecuted they the prophets which were before you. Matthew 5:10-12 For this, compared with the greatness of the other, is far less, yet in regard to the being near, and believing, it is great and sufficient, and has much force. This then was the sharing in the commonwealth. His word is not, separated, but alienated from the commonwealth. His word is not, ye took no interest in, but, ye had not so much as any part in, and were strangers. The expressions are most emphatic, and indicate the separation to be very wide. Because the Israelites themselves were without this commonwealth, not however as aliens, but as indifferent to it, and they fell from the covenants, not however as strangers, but as unworthy.
But what were the covenants of the promise? To you and to your seed, says He, will I give this land, Genesis 17:8 and whatever else He promised.
Having no hope, he adds, and without God. Though gods indeed they worshipped, but they were no gods: for an idol is not any thing. 1 Corinthians 10:19